Automobile Magazine selects an annual list of All-Stars as their Car of the Year equivalent award.
2004
- Automobile of the Year: Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution
- Technology of the Year: BMW Active Steering
- Man of the Year: Martin Leach
- All-Star Coupe: Mazda RX-8
- All-Star Family Car: Mazda Mazda6
- All-Star GT: BMW M3
- All-Star Large Sport Utility: Land Rover Range Rover
- All-Star Luxury Car Over $40,000: Audi A8 L
- All-Star Luxury Car Under $40,000: BMW 3-Series
- All-Star Mid-Size Sport Utility: Cadillac SRX
- All-Star Minivan: Honda Odyssey
- All-Star Pickup Truck: Nissan Titan
- All-Star Small Car: Mini Cooper
- All-Star Sports Car: Porsche Boxster
- All-Star Sport Sedan: Cadillac CTS V
- All-Star Supercar: Ferrari 360 Modena
- All-Star Small Sport Utility: Honda Element
2003
- Automobile of the Year: Nissan 350Z
- All-Star Coupe: Infiniti G35
- All-Star Family Car: Mazda Mazda6
- All-Star GT: BMW M3
- All-Star Large Sport-Utility: Land Rover Range Rover
- All-Star Luxury Car Over $40,000: BMW 7-Series
- All-Star Luxury Car Under $40,000: BMW 3-Series
- All-Star Mid-Size Sport-Utility: Lexus GX470
- All-Star Minivan: Honda Odyssey
- All-Star Pickup Truck: Chevrolet Silverado/GMC Sierra
- All-Star Small Car: Ford Focus
- All-Star Small Sport-Utility: Honda Element
- All-Star Sport Sedan: Subaru Impreza WRX/BMW M5 (tie)
- All-Star Sports Car: Porsche Boxster
- All-Star Supercar: Porsche 911 Turbo/GT2
2002
- Best Coupe: Ford Focus SVT
- Best Family Car: Volkswagen Passat
- Best GT: BMW M3
- Best Large Sport-Utility Vehicle: Toyota Land Cruiser
- Best Luxury Car Over $40,000: Lexus LS 430
- Best Luxury Car Under $40,000: BMW 525i
- Best Mid-Size Sport-Utility Vehicle: Acura MDX
- Best Minivan: Honda Odyssey
- Best Pickup Truck: Chevrolet Silverado/GMC Sierra
- Best Small Car: Ford Focus
- Best Small Sport-Utility Vehicle: Land Rover Freelander
- Best Sport Sedan/Wagon: BMW M5
- Best Sports Car Over $40,000: Porsche Boxster S
- Best Sports Car Under $40,000: Mazda Miata
2001
- Best Coupe: BMW 3-Series
- Best Family Sedan/Wagon: Volkswagen Passat
- Best GT Car: Porsche 911 Carrera
- Best Large SUV: Chevrolet Suburban/GMC Yukon XL
- Best Luxury Sedan/Wagon Over $40,000: Mercedes-Benz S-Class
- Best Luxury Sedan/Wagon Under $40,000: BMW 525i/530i
- Best Midsize SUV: BMW X5
- Best Minivan: Chrysler Town and Country/Dodge Caravan
- Best Pick-Up Truck: Chevrolet Silverado/GMC Sierra
- Best Small Car: Chrysler PT Cruiser
- Best Small SUV: Ford Escape/Mazda Tribute
- Best Sports Car Over $40,000: Porsche 911 Turbo
- Best Sports Car Under $40,000: Chevrolet Corvette
- Best Sports Sedan: BMW M5
